Sharpie Water Based Paint Marker

How Durable Are They

Sharpie Oil Based Paint Pen vs. Water Based. Leaking Paint?

I let my lettering dry for another five minutes or so and then started the next steps.

I wanted to see what would happen if I wiped, touched, scratched, etc.


First, I just ran my finger across each one. I wasnt super gentle I pushed down on each one. And. no worries! Neither were impacted at all.

The real test comes with scratching it though!

When I used my fingernail and to scratch across the lettering, the water-based came off instantly pretty easily.

But when I did the same thing on the oil-based, it didnt budge.

This is one of the key differences between the two, especially on a window. Oil-based is much more durable than water-based even though its not quite as bright white. Its kind of a trade off.

Dry Paper Towel

Next, I used a dry paper towel and wiped the lettering. Water-based came off pretty easily. I got the w off completely by pushing a bit harder. When I didnt push as hard, all the lettering was still pretty scratched.

When I did the same , absolutely nothing happened.

Can Sharpie Oil Based Pens Be Used To Decorate Glass

All Sharpie permanent makers will write on glass. However, to create a more permanent design use Oil-Based Sharpie Paint Markers. The paint makers are specially designed to write on glass, pottery, ceramic, wood, and more! You can remove Sharpie Paint Markers from glass if you make a mistake or just want a new design.

Which Sharpie Pens Are Oil Based


  • Dries in minutes, resists fading and smearing.
  • Oil-based markers are permanent, AP-certified.
  • Works on virtually any surface – metal, pottery, wood, rubber, glass, plastic, stone, and more.
  • Paint markers resist water damage, fading, and abrasion.

Recommended Reading: Walmart In Painted Post Ny

So Which One Is The Winner: Water

There really isnt an answer since they both have their pros and cons.

Water-based is really juicy and really easy to use. Its really opaque and the paint runs really well.

Oil-based is less opaque and less easy to use because it dries faster, but it stays on longer.

So lets say you had a client who had a window/glass storefront and were worried people might go up to it and scratch it. You wouldnt want to use water-based paint pens because the paint will scratch off easily. Youd want to use oil-based paint pens in this situation.

But if you were doing a sign for someone that will be super up high and wont get touched at all once its hung up, water-based paint pens would be totally fine. Theyre more opaque and are a little easier to work with. And a lot easier to remove if your client is worried about it.

Now that you know the pros and cons of each one, you can make an informed decision on which one to use based on what the client wants, how durable it needs to be, how easily it needs to be removed, etc.

How Can You Tell If Paint Is Oil Or Water

Sharpie Water

Rub the damp cotton ball/pad or cotton swab over a small area on the surface. If the paint does not rub off, it is oil-based paint and you will need to prime the surface. If the paint comes off, it is a water or latex-based paint and you can proceed by painting over the surface with any type of paint.

Recommended Reading: Green Modern Exterior House Paint

Sharpie Paint Marker Testing And Swatching

When we tested the paint pens on regular paper we found that the pigment didn’t come through the paper like regular sharpies, just a bit of ghosting showed through.

If you are using a thicker paper, these paint markers won’t show ghosting at all.

When using a Sharpie marker, they glide easily onto a glass surface. This is a fun way to make personalized wine glasses for friends and family.

Another cute idea would be to use these markers to write on water glasses or cups if you were having a tea party or birthday party.

To clean the paint off, use soapy water and a sponge. If you are looking for a super easy project with no mess, these paint markers clean up really easily. Just use an abrasive sponge to clean the paint off of glass.

The colors of these paint markers are really bright and bold on dark surfaces. Paint markers work great on foam core for making posters.

If you have a large pen and marker collection, its very helpful to swatch them out when you purchase a new set. That way you can flip through your swatch book to find the perfect pen for the project you are working on. You can .

We hope you found this Sharpie paint marker review helpful.

Did you find this Sharpie review helpful? Please Pin it to your board so you can find it again later.

Is Acrylic Paint Oil

Acrylic paint is different in one key way from oil. Instead of being made of pigment suspended in oil, it’s made of pigment suspended in a polymer emulsion. This gives the paint much different properties than oil-based paint or watercolor. Acrylic paint is better for people who want their paint to dry faster.

Don’t Miss: How To Remove Mold From Painted Walls With Vinegar

How Hard Are They To Remove From The Surfaces And How Do You Actually Remove Them

For removal, first I tried just a paper towel with water.

The lettering from the water-based paint pen came off really easily like super super super easily with the water and paper towel.

The lettering from the oil-based paint pen didnt budge with the water and paper towel. Literally nothing happened, and I went over it a bunch of times.

This is another big benefit of the oil-based paint pens.


Next I tried with a paper towel and Windex.

The lettering from the water-based paint pen came off instantly with Windex, which I expected. Water-based can be removed super easily by scratching, with a dry paper towel, with water, and with Windex. Super easy to remove.

I used the same paper towel with Windex on it and went over the oil-based lettering. Again, nothing happened.

So if youre working on glass or a window or a mirror with an oil-based paint pen and get smudges on it, you can wipe it off with anything , and it wont damage your writing. STILL BE CAREFUL WITH THIS. Its not permanent and will come off if you scrub hard enough. But in general, you can wipe off smudges without damaging your lettering if you wipe pretty lightly.

So How the heck do you get the oil-based paint off?


I put some alcohol on a paper towel and wiped off the oil-based lettering. It came off pretty easily. Alcohol can leave some streakiness, so I typically use Windex after I get everything off with alcohol.

Sharpie Waterbased Paint Markers And Sets

Sharpie Marker vs Oil-Based Paint Pen vs Water-Based Paint Pen | This or That DIY

Waterbased but permanent opaque paint stands out on any color background and will not bleed through paper. Great for mural and poster work, signs and scrapbooking, Sharpie Paint Markers are destined to become a favorite!

The ink in these markers is acid-free, quick-drying, fade-resistant, and …

® Sharpie is a registered trademark.

Products bearing the AP seal of the Art & Creative Materials Institute, Inc. are certified non-toxic. A product can be certified non-toxic only if it contains no materials in sufficient quantities to be toxic or injurious to humans, or to cause acute or chronic health problems.

Products bearing the AP seal of the Art & Creative Materials Institute, Inc. are certified non-toxic. A product can be certified non-toxic only if it contains no materials in sufficient quantities to be toxic or injurious to humans, or to cause acute or chronic health problems.

You May Like: Best Colors To Paint An Office

How To Prime A Sharpie Paint Marker

Paint markers require a few steps to get them ready for use. The initial priming will only need to be done once.

Step 1. With the marker facing up, press the tip all the way in and release.

Step 2. Put the cap back on and shake the paint marker for about 10 seconds. Theres a little ball inside of the marker that mixes everything together.

Always mix the paint before using the markers, especially if they have been sitting for a while.

Now the markers are ready to be primed. Sharpie paint markers have a spring-loaded tip so as you press down, the paint will start to make its way down into the tip.

Step 3. On a piece of paper press down, press down, press down, you will start to see the paint coming down into the tip. Keep doing this until the tip is fully saturated with paint.

Once the tip of the paint pen is fully saturated with color and you can draw lines that dont break up, its fully primed and ready for use.

Be patient because it can take a bit for the paint to start flowing into the tip of the marker. This is an important step so that your paint pens perform as they should.

If you hear of paint pens not working properly it may have been that the initial priming wasn’t done right. So just make sure the tip is FULLY saturated and you should be good to go.

This paint marker set comes in a fine tip size that’s similar to the size that you would get on a regular sharpie marker. Paint pens come in many tip sizes so be sure to check the details before purchasing.

How Are They To Actually Use Setting Them Up

These were both brand new paint pens still in the packaging. Oil-based paint pens are pink, and the water-based ones are blue. Its easy to remember water is blue.

When I took the caps off, you could see the tips looked the exact same. They were the same shape, but neither had any paint on them.

They work the exact same way. First, I shook them . Shake shake shake.

Then I started to depress the tip until the paint started to flow. You can hold or push down on the tips I just pushed down until the paint flowed.

When depressing them, you can tap up and down a few times and/or hold it down a bit to help get the paint to flow. I did this too. I also recommend rotating your pen a bit as you go.

I did both paint pens at the exact same time, so I could see which one started quicker. The water-based paint pen definitely started faster than the oil-based one. The oil-based one took quite a bit longer to get started.

Also Check: How To Buff Out Paint On Car


Related articles